Areas served: Murfreesboro, TN and surrounding Rutherford County
Murfreesboro's insurance market serves over 150,000 residents across Rutherford County with a mix of national carriers and independent agencies. The local market includes specialists in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, with many agents offering bundled policies for Tennessee-specific needs including tornado coverage and flood insurance considerations. Insurance agents in this directory have been evaluated based on their carrier relationships, coverage options, customer service responsiveness, and competitive pricing structures.
Synergy Insurance is a full-service independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro specializing in auto, home, business, and life insurance. Led by managing partners Jason Shields and Blake Prow, they work with top-tier insurers including Erie Insurance to provide customized coverage solutions for individuals and businesses across middle Tennessee. Their team is known for responsive service, competitive quotes from multiple carriers, and expertise in bundling policies to meet specific client needs.
Acuity Health Advisors is a health insurance and Medicare brokerage in Murfreesboro specializing in personalized guidance for Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap), and individual health insurance plans. Led by advisor Kristen Maurice, they provide no-cost consultation and enrollment assistance for Medicare beneficiaries and individuals seeking coverage, including dental, vision, and supplemental plans. Their approach emphasizes finding the right plan for each client's specific needs, budget, and doctor preferences rather than pushing sales.
Tennessee Auto Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency serving Tennessee for over 20 years with locations in Murfreesboro and Smyrna. They specialize in auto insurance but also offer homeowners, renters, commercial auto, motorcycle, boat, and RV coverage by shopping multiple carriers to find the right fit for each customer. Their experienced staff handles the quote process and policy management so customers can focus on what matters most.
AmeriAgency is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro founded by Baird Morgan, specializing in auto, home, and business insurance. They represent multiple top-tier carriers and provide personalized quotes, policy binding, and ongoing service with annual policy reviews to ensure competitive rates. Their mission centers on educating clients about insurance products while delivering expert guidance tailored to individual coverage needs and budgets.
Shane Miller is a Comparion Insurance Agency executive agent in Murfreesboro offering personalized insurance solutions across auto, home, life, jewelry, and pet coverage. He shops multiple top-rated carriers to find tailored policies that fit your unique needs and budget, handling the comparison work so you don't have to. With licensing across five states and a commitment to exceptional service, Shane's team takes the stress out of protecting what matters most.
BAM Insurance, Inc. is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro serving individuals, families, and business owners throughout Tennessee. They specialize in auto, home, life, umbrella, motorcycle, boat, flood, classic car, condo, renters, motor home, and business liability insurance. As a local independent agent, they shop multiple carriers to find personalized coverage and competitive rates tailored to each client's specific needs.
Miller Loughry Beach Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving Murfreesboro and Middle Tennessee with comprehensive personal and business insurance solutions. They specialize in auto, home, and recreational vehicle coverage for individuals, plus business insurance including workers' compensation, directors and officers liability, employee benefits, and commercial bonds. Known for their consultative approach and genuine partnership with clients, their team provides personalized guidance and accessible support through claims and coverage reviews.
Garrett-Thompson Insurance Advisors LLC is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro serving Middle Tennessee with comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. As an independent agent, they represent multiple carriers, allowing them to compare quotes and find the best rates and coverage for each client's unique needs. Their team works closely with individuals and businesses to build customized insurance solutions.
Acceptance Insurance is a local insurance agency in Murfreesboro offering auto, home, and life insurance coverage. They provide personalized quotes and policy options to help customers find affordable protection tailored to their needs. With flexible coverage plans and competitive rates, they serve drivers and homeowners throughout Middle Tennessee.
Derrick Maddox is an Allstate Insurance agent serving Murfreesboro and surrounding Middle Tennessee communities. He offers comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage tailored to individual and family needs. With personalized service and access to Allstate's full product line, he helps customers find the right protection at competitive rates.
615 Insurance Agency LLC is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro specializing in auto, home, life, and business insurance coverage. They work with multiple carriers to provide personalized quotes and bundle discounts, helping clients find the right protection at competitive rates. The agency focuses on building long-term relationships with their clients through transparent service and tailored insurance solutions.
The Client's Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro specializing in auto, home, business, and life insurance for individuals and businesses throughout Tennessee. Founded on client-first principles, they partner with reputable carriers including Erie Insurance to offer competitive rates, broad coverage options, and personalized service with prompt response times and honest guidance.
Conner Insurance Group is a veteran-owned insurance agency in Murfreesboro serving Middle Tennessee with comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. Founded on principles of service and integrity, they work with clients to customize policies that fit individual needs and budgets, offering competitive rates and personalized support from licensed agents.
Goosehead Insurance, represented by agent Devon Eubanks, is an independent insurance agency serving Nashville and the surrounding area. As a Goosehead franchise, Devon provides personalized insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and commercial coverage by comparing quotes from multiple carriers to find clients the best rates and coverage options. With a focus on customer service and competitive pricing, Goosehead helps individuals and families protect what matters most.
Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service is a locally-owned agency in Murfreesboro run by Stefanie Galué and Eduardo Galue, offering comprehensive auto, home, business, and specialty insurance alongside full-service tax preparation. They represent multiple insurance carriers to find competitive rates for personal and commercial coverage, and provide tax filing for individuals, partnerships, corporations, and trusts with e-file and multi-state services.
Middle TN Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro specializing in auto, home, life, and business insurance coverage. They work with multiple carriers to provide customized quotes and bundling options that help clients save on their overall insurance costs. Their team focuses on understanding each client's unique needs to deliver personalized coverage solutions.
Shelter Insurance agent Blake Finney provides comprehensive insurance coverage including auto, home, life, and business policies to Murfreesboro residents and surrounding areas. As an independent Shelter Insurance agent, Blake offers personalized service and competitive rates, helping customers find the right coverage to protect what matters most.
Cheryl Davis is a local Farmers Insurance agent serving Murfreesboro and surrounding communities. She provides personalized insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage, helping families and business owners protect what matters most with competitive rates and local service.
Farmers Insurance agent Stuart Hamilton provides comprehensive insurance coverage including auto, home, life, and business policies to Murfreesboro and surrounding Middle Tennessee communities. As an independent Farmers agent, Stuart offers personalized service and bundle discounts to help customers find the right coverage at competitive rates.
Farm Bureau Insurance in Murfreesboro is a full-service insurance agency offering auto, home, life, and business coverage through Tennessee Farm Bureau. The agency provides personalized insurance solutions tailored to protect families and businesses across Middle Tennessee, with local agents dedicated to helping customers find the right coverage at competitive rates.
The Newport Agency is an independent insurance agency serving Murfreesboro and the surrounding area with personalized coverage solutions across multiple insurance lines. Their team specializes in matching clients with competitive rates and comprehensive policies, whether for auto, home, business, or life insurance needs. They focus on understanding each client's unique situation to recommend the right coverage and discounts.
My Team Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro offering comprehensive coverage including auto, home, life, and business insurance. With a focus on personalized service and competitive rates, they help individuals and businesses find the right protection for their needs.
Direct Auto Insurance is a local insurance agency in Murfreesboro offering auto insurance, home insurance, and other coverage options. They provide competitive rates and personalized service to help customers find affordable protection for their vehicles and homes. With a focus on quick quotes and flexible payment options, Direct Auto serves customers throughout Middle Tennessee.
Service Insurance Agency, Inc. is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro representing Erie Insurance, offering comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. The agency helps local residents and business owners find tailored insurance solutions with personalized service and competitive rates.
Acceptance Insurance is a full-service insurance agency in Smyrna offering auto, home, and life insurance coverage to Tennessee residents. They provide personalized quotes and policy options tailored to individual needs, helping customers find affordable coverage that fits their budget.
ReduceMyInsurance is an independent insurance agency in Murfreesboro helping individuals and families find affordable coverage across auto, home, life, and business insurance. They specialize in comparing quotes from multiple carriers to identify the best rates and bundling opportunities for each client's unique situation.
More Insurance LLC is an independent insurance agency serving Murfreesboro and the surrounding area. They provide comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage, working with multiple carriers to find clients the best rates and options for their specific needs.
Synergy Insurance is the top-ranked insurance agency in Murfreesboro with a Lantern Score of 85.49/100 and a 5-star rating from 317 reviews. Led by managing partners Jason Shields and Blake Prow, they specialize in auto, home, business, and life insurance and are particularly known for serving Middle Tennessee families and business owners seeking bundled coverage.
Acuity Health Advisors is the top choice for Medicare beneficiaries, ranking #2 with a Lantern Score of 85.13/100 and 5-star rating from 166 reviews. They specialize in personalized guidance for Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap), and individual health insurance, making them ideal for those new to Medicare or comparing coverage options.
Murfreesboro has several specialized auto insurance providers. Tennessee Auto Insurance Agency (#3, Lantern Score 84.10) has over 20 years of experience and serves drivers seeking competitive rates, while Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service (#15, Lantern Score 80.32) offers auto coverage alongside tax preparation services, making it ideal for self-employed individuals and small business owners.
For small business commercial coverage, Miller Loughry Beach Insurance (#7, Lantern Score 82.86) specializes in serving small to mid-size business owners, while BAM Insurance, Inc. (#6, Lantern Score 83.57) specifically focuses on commercial liability coverage. Both agencies provide personalized business insurance solutions tailored to Tennessee companies.
Yes, Conner Insurance Group, LLC (#13, Lantern Score 81.38) is a veteran-owned agency serving Middle Tennessee with a 5-star rating from 137 reviews. They offer comprehensive coverage including auto, home, life, and business insurance, founded on principles of supporting veterans and the community.
Multiple top-ranked agencies offer family bundling, but Synergy Insurance (#1, Lantern Score 85.49) and Tennessee Auto Insurance Agency (#3, Lantern Score 84.10) are among the highest-rated options for families seeking bundled auto and home coverage with competitive multi-carrier quotes.