Best Insurance Agents in Kissimmee, Florida

    Areas served: Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Osceola County

    23 local businessesRanked by Lantern Score — a measure of reputation and business quality. We don't accept payment for placement.
    Updated April 21, 2026

    Kissimmee's insurance market serves a diverse population including year-round residents, vacation property owners, and small business operators in the tourism corridor. Local agents must navigate Florida-specific considerations like hurricane coverage, flood insurance requirements, and the state's unique auto insurance regulations. This directory provides verified insurance agents in Kissimmee, evaluated on their product range, carrier access, claims support, and understanding of Central Florida's insurance landscape.

    Show businesses best for:
    86
    Lantern
    Score
    Orlando, FL · 14 mi from Kissimmee
    Serves Orlando, Florida and throughout Florida, Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, and Tennessee
    ★★★★★5.0(483 Google reviews)

    Health and Life Insurance Group LLC is a family-run insurance brokerage in Orlando specializing in affordable health, life, dental, and vision coverage. With 18 years of experience and multilingual advisors fluent in English, Urdu, Hindi, and Bangla, they serve families and individuals across Florida, Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, and Tennessee. They offer ACA/Obamacare, Medicare, private health insurance, group employer plans, life insurance, and supplemental coverage—handling everything from free consultations and subsidy verification to same-day enrollment, with extended hours seven days a week.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsSaving Money
    Ideal clients: Families seeking affordable health insurance, self-employed professionals, individuals navigating ACA enrollment, Medicare-eligible seniors, multilingual households, employers needing group coverage
    What sets them apart
    • Available 7 days a week, 8 AM–11 PM, with advisors fluent in English, Urdu, Hindi, Bangla, and more to serve diverse families.
    • Represents major insurance carriers rather than being tied to one company, giving clients real options and competitive rates.
    • Specializes in fast enrollment and verifying tax credits and subsidies, plus expertise with complicated situations like denied Medicaid or recent immigrants.
    Health InsuranceLife InsuranceACA PlansMedicareAffordable Coverage
    Phone(407) 337-9862
    Health and Life Insurance Group LLC
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Orlando, FL · 17 mi from Kissimmee
    Serves Orlando and surrounding Central Florida areas
    ★★★★★5.0(238 Google reviews)

    Senic Insurance Group is a Florida-based insurance agency with over 25 years of experience serving 5,000+ customers. They offer comprehensive coverage including auto, home, life, health, medical, commercial, and restaurant insurance through partnerships with multiple carriers. Known for personalized service, competitive rates, and bilingual support, they guide clients through policy selection and claims management to ensure appropriate coverage for their specific needs.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking multi-policy bundling, small business owners, families needing life and health coverage, Spanish-speaking Floridians
    What sets them apart
    • Established insurance agency with over two decades of expertise and a track record of serving over 5,000 satisfied customers across Florida.
    • Represents 30+ insurance companies, allowing them to compare coverage options and provide competitive rates tailored to individual needs.
    • Offers Spanish-language services, making insurance guidance and policy management accessible to diverse communities in Florida.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceCommercial InsuranceBilingual Service
    Phone(407) 574-2051
    Senic Insurance Group
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, Florida and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★5.0(217 Google reviews)

    Power Insurance Financial is a Kissimmee-based insurance agency specializing in life insurance, health insurance, and annuities. With over 15 years of experience and a team of 100+ agents, they serve 1,200+ families with personalized financial protection solutions. The agency focuses on tailored coverage that helps clients secure their futures and achieve their financial goals through comprehensive life and health insurance policies and flexible retirement annuity options.

    Best for: Life Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Families seeking comprehensive life insurance, individuals planning for retirement with annuities, people shopping for health insurance coverage
    What sets them apart
    • Power Insurance Financial employs over 100 licensed agents dedicated to providing personalized service and tailored financial solutions to each client.
    • With over 15 years in the insurance and financial services industry, the agency brings deep expertise in life insurance, health coverage, and retirement planning.
    • The agency has built strong relationships with over 1,200 families and manages over $3M in protection and investment products.
    Life InsuranceHealth InsuranceAnnuitiesFinancial ProtectionRetirement Planning
    Power Insurance Financial
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Osceola County areas
    ★★★★★5.0(180 Google reviews)

    Acceptance Insurance is a local insurance agency in Kissimmee offering comprehensive auto, home, renters, motorcycle, boat, and life insurance coverage. With agents who understand the specific needs of Kissimmee residents, they specialize in finding affordable policies for high-risk drivers, SR-22 coverage, and standard auto insurance. They also provide business insurance, pet insurance, and additional protection products like roadside assistance and identity theft protection.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: High-risk drivers needing SR-22 coverage, motorcycle owners, renters, homeowners, small business owners, first-time insurance shoppers
    What sets them apart
    • Agents compare quotes from multiple reliable carriers to help you find the best rates for your specific situation.
    • Expert handling of high-risk, SR-22, and FR-44 insurance needs, plus coverage for motorcycles, boats, RVs, and Mexican auto insurance.
    • Walk-in office at 2439 Pleasant Hill Road with agents who understand Kissimmee's specific insurance needs and local driving conditions.
    Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceSR-22 CoverageAffordable RatesLocal Agent
    Phone(407) 586-7654
    Acceptance Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee and central Florida
    ★★★★★5.0(128 Google reviews)

    Familia Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee serving central Florida families and businesses. They specialize in auto, home, flood, and commercial insurance, and also offer condo, motorcycle, RV, boat, life, health, and renters coverage. As independent agents, they work with multiple carriers to help clients find personalized insurance solutions tailored to Florida's unique risk environment.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Florida homeowners, business owners, auto insurance shoppers, families seeking bundled coverage, those needing flood insurance
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to compare rates and coverage options, giving clients more choices than captive agents.
    • Offers auto, home, flood, commercial, condo, motorcycle, RV, boat, life, health, and renters insurance all in one location.
    • Specializes in Florida-specific insurance needs including flood protection and hurricane-related coverage for homes and businesses.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceIndependent AgentCommercial InsuranceFlorida Insurance
    Phone(407) 344-0700
    Familia Insurance Agency
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee and Central Florida
    ★★★★★5.0(100 Google reviews)

    Insurance Pro is a licensed insurance agency in Kissimmee with over 12 years of experience serving Central Florida families and individuals. They specialize in Medicare (Advantage, Supplement, and Part D), ACA/health insurance, life insurance (term, whole, universal, final expense, and mortgage protection), annuities, and dental and vision coverage. The agency also offers home and auto insurance, with a team of knowledgeable bilingual agents dedicated to finding personalized coverage solutions.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Medicare-eligible seniors, families seeking comprehensive health coverage, individuals shopping for life insurance protection, Hispanic families in Central Florida
    What sets them apart
    • Insurance Pro has deep expertise in Florida's insurance market and is recognized as one of the fastest growing agencies in the Hispanic market with multiple licensed agents.
    • Beyond Medicare and health insurance, they offer life insurance, annuities, dental, vision, home, auto, final expense, and mortgage protection policies—a full-service insurance solution.
    • Their team works hand-in-hand with clients to match individual needs with the best available products from multiple carriers, with bilingual support available.
    MedicareHealth InsuranceLife InsuranceLicensed AgentsFamily Coverage
    Phone(407) 847-7000
    Insurance Pro
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, Apopka, and throughout Florida
    ★★★★★5.0(88 Google reviews)

    The Insurance Store USA is an independent insurance agency with locations in Kissimmee and Apopka, Florida, specializing in auto, home, renters, and business insurance. Founded to provide competitive rates and personalized service, they work with over 20 insurance carriers to compare coverage options and find the best plans tailored to each client's needs. Their bilingual Spanish-speaking agents provide advisory-focused service, same-day SR-22 filings, and flexible coverage options across all of Florida.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness Owners
    Ideal clients: Spanish-speaking and English-speaking homeowners, auto drivers needing affordable coverage, small business owners, customers seeking personalized advisory service
    What sets them apart
    • Represents over 20 insurance companies, allowing agents to compare quotes and find the lowest rates tailored to your specific needs rather than pushing a single carrier's products.
    • Fluent Spanish-speaking agents provide personalized service to Spanish-speaking clients, ensuring clear communication and understanding of coverage options.
    • Offers expedited SR-22 processing with instant ID cards and flexible low down payments for quick policy activation.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceIndependent AgentBilingual Service
    Phone(407) 705-3605
    The Insurance Store USA
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(2262 Google reviews)

    Univista Insurance is a full-service insurance agency in Kissimmee led by agent Yoisel Gonzalez, specializing in personalized insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. They offer auto, home, health (including Obamacare), life, commercial, and pet insurance, partnering with over 20 carriers to provide competitive rates and comprehensive coverage. Bilingual service in English and Spanish with a commitment to expert guidance and quick response times.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Bilingual families seeking personalized service, small business owners needing commercial coverage, individuals comparing auto and health insurance rates
    What sets them apart
    • Partners with over 20 insurance companies to compare rates and find the best coverage options for each client's unique needs.
    • Offers personalized service in both English and Spanish with knowledgeable staff dedicated to explaining coverage options in detail.
    • Provides free quotes across all insurance types—auto, home, health, life, commercial, and pet—with quick response times (approximately 2 minutes).
    Auto InsuranceHealth InsuranceBusiness InsuranceLife InsuranceBilingual Service
    Phone(407) 964-1727
    Univista Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(645 Google reviews)

    Familia Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee serving Central Florida families and businesses with comprehensive coverage options. They specialize in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, offering personalized service and competitive quotes from multiple carriers. With a focus on understanding each client's unique needs, Familia Insurance helps residents and business owners protect what matters most.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Central Florida families seeking auto and home insurance, business owners needing commercial coverage, individuals looking for life insurance, customers who value personalized service and competitive quotes
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agency, Familia Insurance works with multiple insurance carriers, allowing them to compare rates and coverage options to find the best fit for each client's situation.
    • The agency takes time to understand your specific needs and life circumstances, providing tailored insurance solutions rather than one-size-fits-all recommendations.
    • Familia Insurance offers auto, home, life, and commercial insurance under one roof, making it convenient for families and business owners to manage all their insurance needs.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceCommercial InsuranceIndependent Agent
    Phone(407) 847-8007
    Familia Insurance Agency
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Orlando, FL · 5 mi from Kissimmee
    Serves Orlando and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(368 Google reviews)

    MLR Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Orlando offering comprehensive coverage across homeowners, auto, life, and business insurance. Their experienced team works with multiple carriers to provide personalized quotes and help clients find the right coverage at competitive rates. They specialize in bundling policies to maximize savings for families and business owners throughout Central Florida.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking bundled coverage, small business owners, families looking to consolidate auto and home insurance, those comparing multi-carrier quotes
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agent, MLR Insurance Group works with multiple carriers rather than a single company, giving clients access to a wider range of quotes and coverage options.
    • They specialize in bundling homeowners, auto, life, and business insurance to help clients save money and simplify their policies in one place.
    • Based in Orlando with direct phone access and online tools, they provide personalized service tailored to Central Florida residents' specific insurance needs.
    Insurance AgencyIndependent AgentAuto & HomeBusiness InsuranceFree Quotes
    MLR Insurance Group
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    83
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, Florida and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(123 Google reviews)

    GreatFlorida Insurance in Kissimmee is an independent insurance agency run by Kelvin & Charlene Taveras, offering personalized coverage solutions for auto, home, life, and business insurance needs. As an independent agent, they work with multiple carriers to find competitive rates and customized policies tailored to each client's specific situation. Their local presence and direct relationships with customers set them apart in the Kissimmee community.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Central Florida residents seeking auto and home insurance, small business owners, individuals looking to bundle multiple policies, homeowners in hurricane-prone areas
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agent, Kelvin & Charlene represent multiple insurance companies, allowing them to compare rates and coverage options to find the best fit for each client rather than being limited to a single carrier.
    • Run by Kelvin & Charlene Taveras, this agency provides direct, personal relationships with clients in the Kissimmee area, offering customized insurance solutions based on individual circumstances.
    • They provide auto, home, life, and business insurance under one roof, making it easy to bundle policies and manage all insurance needs with a single trusted agency.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceIndependent AgentLife InsuranceBusiness Insurance
    Phone(407) 931-3729
    GreatFlorida Insurance: Kelvin & Charlene Taveras
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    83
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(103 Google reviews)

    Florida One Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee serving Central Florida with comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. They work with multiple carriers to provide personalized quotes and competitive rates tailored to each client's needs. The agency specializes in finding bundling discounts and customized coverage solutions for families and small business owners throughout the region.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Families seeking home and auto bundling, small business owners needing commercial coverage, individuals looking for competitive life insurance rates
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agency, Florida One Insurance partners with multiple insurance carriers, enabling them to compare rates and coverage options to find the best fit for each client rather than being limited to a single company's offerings.
    • Conveniently located in Kissimmee with direct phone and online support, making it easy for local residents and business owners to access personalized insurance consultations and policy management.
    • Offers auto, home, life, and business insurance under one roof, allowing customers to bundle policies and access potential discounts while simplifying their insurance management.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceIndependent Agent
    Phone(786) 501-2059
    Florida One Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.8(498 Google reviews)

    Estrella Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee offering personalized coverage solutions for auto, home, life, and business insurance. The agency specializes in helping families and business owners find affordable policies tailored to their specific needs, with multilingual support and flexible payment options. They work with multiple carriers to ensure clients get competitive rates and comprehensive protection.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Families seeking auto and home insurance, small business owners, multilingual customers, budget-conscious households looking for competitive rates
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agent, Estrella works with various insurance companies to compare rates and coverage options, ensuring clients get the best value for their specific situation.
    • The agency provides personalized service with bilingual staff to serve the diverse Kissimmee community.
    • Estrella offers multiple payment options to make insurance accessible and manageable for families and businesses of all sizes.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceIndependent Agent
    Phone(407) 505-4045
    Estrella Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Orlando, FL · 16 mi from Kissimmee
    Serves Orlando and Central Florida, including surrounding areas across Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Texas
    ★★★★★5.0(1014 Google reviews)

    Accent Brokers Insurance is a family-owned independent insurance agency serving Central Florida since 2006, specializing in auto, homeowners, commercial, and specialty insurance for contractors and truckers. They partner with top-tier insurance carriers across six states to deliver personalized service and competitive rates for both individuals and businesses, with a reputation for exceptional customer responsiveness and attention to detail.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving Money
    Ideal clients: Small business owners and contractors, homebuyers and homeowners, truck drivers and fleet operators, families seeking bundled auto and home coverage
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent broker, Accent Brokers partners with multiple top insurance companies to offer clients competitive rates and personalized quotes rather than representing a single carrier.
    • Their commercial department has deep expertise serving contractors and truckers, providing tailored coverage for specialized business needs beyond standard commercial policies.
    • Established in 2006, the agency actively serves the American, Brazilian, and Hispanic communities in Central Florida with bilingual support and culturally responsive service.
    Independent AgentAuto InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceCommercial InsuranceFamily-Owned
    Phone(407) 306-0101
    Accent Brokers Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and Central Florida
    ★★★★★4.9(56 Google reviews)

    Harrell Insurance is an independent insurance agency serving the Kissimmee area and Central Florida with personalized coverage solutions. They specialize in auto, home, life, and business insurance, helping individuals and families find the right policies at competitive rates. With a focus on customer service and local expertise, Harrell Insurance works to match clients with coverage that fits their specific needs and budget.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Families seeking bundled insurance savings, small business owners, Central Florida residents needing personalized coverage advice
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to find the best rates and coverage options for each client, rather than being tied to a single company.
    • Based in Kissimmee with deep knowledge of Central Florida's specific insurance needs and local market conditions.
    • Offers auto, home, life, and business insurance in one convenient location, making it easy to bundle policies and manage all coverage needs.
    Independent AgentAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness Insurance
    Phone(407) 846-6421
    Harrell Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Orlando, FL · 4 mi from Kissimmee
    Serves Orlando and surrounding central Florida communities
    ★★★★★5.0(241 Google reviews)

    JW Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Orlando serving central Florida with personalized coverage solutions across auto, home, life, and business insurance. Their team works directly with clients to assess individual needs and find competitive rates from multiple carriers, ensuring customers get the right protection at the best value.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking competitive rates, business owners needing commercial coverage, individuals wanting bundled auto and home insurance, those comparing multiple carriers
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to compare rates and coverage options, giving clients access to competitive pricing from different companies rather than being limited to one insurer.
    • Takes time to understand each client's specific situation and insurance needs, then recommends tailored solutions rather than one-size-fits-all policies.
    • Long-standing Orlando agency with a central location, providing convenient access and continuity of service for personal and business insurance needs.
    Independent Insurance AgencyAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness Insurance
    JW Insurance Group
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    80
    Lantern
    Score
    Orlando, FL · 5 mi from Kissimmee
    Serves Orlando and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(1233 Google reviews)

    Garzor Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Orlando serving Florida residents with comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. They work with multiple carriers to provide customized policies and competitive rates, helping clients find the right coverage at the right price.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, auto owners, small business operators, families seeking life insurance
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to compare options and find the best coverage and rates for each client's unique needs.
    • Offers auto, home, life, and business insurance all in one location, making it convenient to manage multiple policies.
    • Orlando-based agency with deep knowledge of Florida-specific insurance needs and local market conditions.
    Insurance AgencyAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness Insurance
    Phone(321) 206-8035
    Garzor Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    80
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.9(389 Google reviews)

    Laura Moody is a State Farm Insurance Agent serving the Kissimmee area with comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and business coverage. As a State Farm representative, Laura offers personalized service to help customers find the right protection for their needs, backed by one of the nation's largest and most trusted insurance providers.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, auto owners, families seeking life insurance, small business owners, bundling customers looking for discounts
    What sets them apart
    • Access to State Farm's extensive coverage options and financial stability as one of America's largest insurers.
    • Direct relationship with a knowledgeable local agent who understands the specific insurance needs of Kissimmee residents.
    • Bundle auto, home, life, and business insurance for potential discounts and simplified account management.
    State FarmAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife Insurance
    Phone(321) 677-4148
    Laura Moody - State Farm Insurance Agent
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    80
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee and Central Florida
    ★★★★★4.7(166 Google reviews)

    Direct Auto Insurance is a local insurance agency in Kissimmee offering auto insurance, home insurance, and other coverage options. As an independent agent, they work with multiple carriers to provide competitive quotes and personalized coverage tailored to your needs. They focus on making insurance accessible and affordable with flexible payment options and bundling discounts for customers.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersSaving Money
    Ideal clients: Budget-conscious drivers, Homeowners seeking bundled coverage, Those comparing insurance rates
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agent, they compare quotes from multiple insurance carriers to find you the best rates and coverage options available.
    • Combine auto and home insurance policies to unlock significant savings on your premiums.
    • Offer convenient payment options to fit your budget while maintaining continuous coverage.
    Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceIndependent AgentLocal Insurance
    Phone(407) 846-7700
    Direct Auto Insurance - N Main St
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    79
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee and Central Florida
    ★★★★★4.9(96 Google reviews)

    Amsley Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee offering comprehensive coverage solutions including auto, home, life, and business insurance. With years of experience serving Central Florida families and businesses, they specialize in finding affordable policies tailored to individual needs and helping clients understand their coverage options.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking bundled coverage, Small business owners, Families looking for comprehensive protection, Auto and home insurance shoppers
    What sets them apart
    • Access to multiple insurance carriers allows them to compare options and find the best rates and coverage for your specific situation.
    • They take time to understand your needs and provide customized recommendations rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
    • Established in the Kissimmee community with deep knowledge of local insurance requirements and regional risks.
    Independent AgentAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceLife Insurance
    Phone(407) 261-4252
    Amsley Insurance Services
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    78
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.8(261 Google reviews)

    Direct Auto Insurance is a local insurance agency in Kissimmee offering affordable auto insurance coverage with flexible payment options and quick policy processing. They specialize in helping drivers find competitive rates and provide in-person service at their Orange Blossom Trail location to assist with quotes, policy changes, and claims support.

    Best for: Comparing Options
    Ideal clients: Budget-conscious drivers, high-risk drivers, those seeking flexible payment plans, drivers needing same-day coverage
    What sets them apart
    • Direct Auto offers multiple payment options to fit different budgets, making insurance more accessible to drivers with varying financial needs.
    • Their Kissimmee location provides face-to-face customer service for quotes, policy adjustments, and support without requiring online-only interactions.
    • Direct Auto specializes in quick policy quotes and same-day or next-day policy activation for customers who need coverage fast.
    Auto InsuranceAffordable RatesLocal AgencyQuick QuotesFlexible Payment
    Phone(407) 932-0211
    Direct Auto Insurance - N Orange Blossom Trail
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    78
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.8(130 Google reviews)

    All Floridian Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee serving Central Florida with comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and commercial insurance. They work with multiple carriers to find clients the best rates and coverage for their specific needs, and pride themselves on personalized service and local expertise.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking competitive rates, Auto insurance shoppers, Small business owners, Families bundling multiple policies
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to compare rates and find the best coverage options for each client's unique situation, rather than being locked into a single company.
    • Based in Kissimmee with direct knowledge of Central Florida insurance needs, including coverage specific to the region's hurricane seasons and local property considerations.
    Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceIndependent AgentLocal Insurance
    All Floridian Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    77
    Lantern
    Score
    Kissimmee, FL
    Serves Kissimmee, FL and surrounding Central Florida communities
    ★★★★★4.8(64 Google reviews)

    Moorehead Professional Insurance Services is an independent insurance agency in Kissimmee offering comprehensive coverage including homeowners, auto, life, and business insurance. With over a decade of local service, they help individuals and businesses find customized policies that fit their specific needs and budgets.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking bundled coverage, Small business owners, Individuals needing auto and home insurance, Those comparing multiple carrier options
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple carriers to provide competitive quotes and options rather than being limited to a single company's products.
    • Based in Kissimmee with deep knowledge of Central Florida's unique insurance needs, including hurricane and weather-related coverage considerations.
    • Takes time to understand each client's specific situation and finds customized solutions rather than one-size-fits-all policies.
    Insurance AgencyIndependent AgentAuto InsuranceHomeowners Insurance
    Phone(407) 518-1111
    Moorehead Professional Insurance Services
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Who is the top-ranked insurance agent in Kissimmee?

    Health and Life Insurance Group LLC is the top-ranked insurance agency in Kissimmee with a Lantern Score of 85.63/100 and a 5-star rating from 483 reviews. They specialize in affordable health, life, dental, and vision coverage with 18 years of experience and multilingual support for families and self-employed professionals.

    Which Kissimmee insurance agencies are best for families needing life and health coverage?

    Power Insurance Financial (Lantern Score: 85.31/100) and Senic Insurance Group (Lantern Score: 85.36/100) are top choices for families seeking comprehensive life and health insurance. Power Insurance Financial has over 15 years of experience with 100+ agents, while Senic Insurance Group brings 25+ years of Florida experience serving 5,000+ customers.

    What insurance options exist for high-risk drivers in Kissimmee?

    Acceptance Insurance (Lantern Score: 85.19/100) specializes in SR-22 coverage for high-risk drivers and has a 5-star rating from 180 reviews. Direct Auto Insurance on N Orange Blossom Trail (Lantern Score: 78.37/100) also serves high-risk drivers with flexible payment options and same-day coverage availability.

    Which agencies in Kissimmee are best for Spanish-speaking customers?

    Univista Insurance (Lantern Score: 84.10/100) led by agent Yoisel Gonzalez specializes in bilingual, personalized service and has a 4.9-star rating from 2,262 reviews. Health and Life Insurance Group LLC (Lantern Score: 85.63/100) is also highly recommended for multilingual households with 18 years of experience.

    Which Kissimmee insurance agencies offer flood insurance?

    Familia Insurance Agency (Lantern Score: 84.91/100) is one of the few agencies in Kissimmee that specializes in flood insurance alongside auto, home, and commercial coverage. They serve Central Florida families and businesses with a 5-star rating from 128 reviews.

    Who specializes in Medicare coverage in Kissimmee?

    Insurance Pro (Lantern Score: 84.65/100) specializes in Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans with over 12 years of experience serving Central Florida. They have a 5-star rating and are particularly recommended for Medicare-eligible seniors and Hispanic families in the area.

    This directory of insurance agents local businesses serving Kissimmee, FL is maintained by Lantern. Rankings are determined by the Lantern Score — not advertising or payment for placement. Learn how it works. Last updated April 21, 2026. To claim or update a listing, contact us.