Best Insurance Agents in Scottsdale, Arizona

    Areas served: Scottsdale, AZ and surrounding areas including Paradise Valley, Fountain Hills, and North Phoenix

    29 local businessesRanked by Lantern Score — a measure of reputation and business quality. We don't accept payment for placement.
    Updated April 21, 2026

    Scottsdale's insurance market serves a diverse clientele ranging from retirees in master-planned communities to small business owners in Old Town and North Scottsdale. Local agents navigate unique regional considerations including monsoon season property coverage, high-value home insurance in areas like Desert Mountain and Silverleaf, and specialized policies for golf cart usage in retirement communities. The insurance landscape includes both captive agents representing single carriers and independent brokers with access to multiple providers across auto, home, business, and life insurance products.

    Show businesses best for:
    86
    Lantern
    Score
    Mesa, AZ · 18 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Mesa, Phoenix metro area, and throughout Arizona
    ★★★★★5.0(1830 Google reviews)

    Insurance Professionals of Arizona is an independent insurance agency in Mesa serving Arizona families and businesses with comprehensive coverage solutions. They specialize in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance from multiple carriers, allowing them to find competitive rates tailored to each client's unique needs. With over 1,800 five-star reviews, they're known for personalized service and expert guidance through the insurance selection process.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Arizona families seeking competitive auto and home insurance, small business owners needing commercial coverage, individuals looking to bundle policies for discounts
    What sets them apart
    • Compare quotes from multiple insurance companies to find the best rates and coverage for your situation, rather than being limited to one carrier's offerings.
    • Offer auto, home, life, and commercial insurance in one convenient location, simplifying your insurance needs and enabling bundling discounts.
    • Mesa-based team with deep knowledge of Arizona's specific insurance requirements and regional risks.
    Independent Insurance AgentAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceCommercial Insurance
    Phone(480) 531-6179
    Insurance Professionals of Arizona
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    86
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Carefree, and greater Phoenix metro area, serving all of Arizona
    ★★★★★5.0(599 Google reviews)

    Jeremy Mueller is a third-generation State Farm Insurance Agent serving Scottsdale, Carefree, and the greater Phoenix metro area since 1999. His agency offers auto, homeowners, condo, renters, life, business, health, and pet insurance, plus banking and investment services through State Farm. With three convenient office locations and a bilingual team, Mueller provides personalized coverage for families, individuals, and business owners across Arizona, recognized by State Farm with multiple awards for excellence.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Families seeking auto and home insurance, new residents relocating to Scottsdale or Phoenix area, small business owners needing commercial coverage, Arizona residents wanting statewide insurance support
    What sets them apart
    • Jeremy Mueller is a lifelong Scottsdale resident and third-generation State Farm Agent with deep community roots since 1999, offering personalized service based on local knowledge.
    • Three convenient offices in Scottsdale and Carefree provide flexible access, plus 24/7 availability by phone, text, or appointment for quotes and claims.
    • Honored with President's Club, Vice President's Club, and Ambassador Travel awards, demonstrating consistent excellence in customer service and sales performance.
    State Farm InsuranceAuto & Home InsuranceLocal AgentBusiness InsuranceLife Insurance
    Jeremy Mueller - State Farm Insurance Agent
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    86
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Arizona and surrounding Phoenix metropolitan area
    ★★★★★5.0(515 Google reviews)

    Shisler & Associates Insurance, Inc is an American Family Insurance agency in Scottsdale, Arizona, led by Bryan Shisler and a dedicated team of experienced agents. They specialize in comprehensive insurance solutions including home, auto, life, umbrella, renters, and business coverage for individuals and families. The agency is known for personalized service, with bilingual support available and expertise in high-value luxury homes, small business coverage, and helping first-time homebuyers find appropriate protection.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: First-time homebuyers, Small business owners, High-value home owners, Families seeking comprehensive life insurance protection
    What sets them apart
    • The team includes bilingual agents (Spanish-speaking) and offers tailored coverage solutions, with specialists dedicated to life insurance consultations and high-value property protection.
    • Shisler & Associates has been serving the community for decades with multiple branch managers and experienced agents, including staff at their Fountain Hills location since 2001.
    • The agency offers home, auto, life, umbrella, renters, and business insurance with bundle discounts available, plus specialized guidance for first-time homebuyers and small business owners.
    American Family InsuranceHome & Auto InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness Coverage
    Phone(480) 951-5056
    Websiteamfam.com
    Shisler & Associates Insurance, Inc American Family Insurance - E Cactus Rd
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 19 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix, Arizona and surrounding areas
    ★★★★★5.0(271 Google reviews)

    Southland Insurance Services is a Phoenix-based independent insurance agency offering comprehensive coverage for individuals, families, and small businesses across Arizona. They specialize in auto, home, life, commercial, and specialty insurance (contractor, motorcycle, RV, commercial auto, general liability, workers' compensation, and umbrella coverage) with personalized service and no extra fees. The agency is particularly known for serving union families through UFCW99, providing exclusive fee-free coverage options, and maintaining 24/7 claims support.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Union families seeking fee-free coverage, small business owners, self-employed contractors, individuals with multiple insurance needs (auto, home, life)
    What sets them apart
    • Exclusive insurance benefits for UFCW99 union members with no extra fees, designed specifically for working families.
    • Offers 13+ types of insurance including auto, home, life, business, contractor, commercial auto, motorcycle, RV, general liability, workers' compensation, and umbrella coverage—all from one agency.
    • Provides round-the-clock claims assistance and quick resolution times, with licensed agents available to guide clients toward the right coverage.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceUnion Member BenefitsLocal Independent Agency
    Southland Insurance Services
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Phoenix, and throughout Arizona
    ★★★★★5.0(222 Google reviews)

    Pinnacle Peak Insurance Group is a family-owned and operated insurance agency in Scottsdale serving Arizona residents and businesses since 2012. They provide a comprehensive one-stop-shop for auto, home, life, commercial, and recreational vehicle insurance, shopping over 50 providers to find competitive rates. With 30 years of combined industry experience, they offer instant online quotes, bundling discounts, and personalized service with live agents who can typically resolve issues within an hour.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Arizona homeowners, auto insurance shoppers, small business owners, families seeking life insurance protection
    What sets them apart
    • Compares rates across 50+ insurance providers to find the best coverage at competitive prices for Arizona customers.
    • Customers always speak with a live person, not automated systems, and most issues are resolved within one hour.
    • Offers auto, home, life, commercial, and RV insurance with bundling discounts available to reduce overall costs.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceCommercial InsuranceLife InsuranceFamily-Owned
    Pinnacle Peak Insurance Group
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Glendale, AZ · 20 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix metro area, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico, and Colorado
    ★★★★★5.0(165 Google reviews)

    Professional Insurance Strategies is a family-owned independent insurance agency serving the Southwest since 2006, with offices in Glendale and Mesa, Arizona. They work with over 50 insurance carriers to provide personalized coverage for auto, home, life, and business insurance at competitive rates. Their team specializes in assessing individual and commercial needs to develop tailored, cost-effective solutions without being tied to a single carrier.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, Auto owners, Small business owners, Commercial account holders seeking multi-carrier options
    What sets them apart
    • Work with over 50 different insurance companies to find the best coverage and rates, rather than being limited to a single carrier.
    • Locally owned and operated independent agency with deep roots in the Southwest and a long-standing commitment to personalized service.
    • Offer personal insurance (auto, home, life) and business insurance (general liability, commercial auto, property, umbrella) all from one agency.
    Independent AgentMulti-Carrier OptionsFamily-OwnedBusiness & Personal InsuranceSouthwest Coverage
    Phone(623) 463-9000
    Professional Insurance Strategies
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    85
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Phoenix, Fountain Hills, Paradise Valley, Cave Creek, and surrounding Arizona communities
    ★★★★★5.0(110 Google reviews)

    Kreisman Insurance Group is an independent insurance broker led by Jim Kreisman, MBA, LUTCF, serving Arizona families and homeowners for over 23 years. They specialize in homeowners insurance, auto insurance, umbrella liability, life insurance, landlord insurance, and coverage for motorcycles, RVs, classic cars, watercraft, and other specialty vehicles. With access to 20+ top-rated carriers including Travelers, Safeco, Nationwide, and Progressive, Jim provides personalized guidance, detailed policy reviews, and hands-on claims support without corporate pressure or upselling.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Arizona homeowners seeking personalized insurance guidance, families adding teen drivers or reviewing coverage gaps, high-net-worth individuals needing umbrella liability, landlords and investment property owners
    What sets them apart
    • Independent broker with access to multiple top-rated insurers, providing unbiased recommendations focused on client needs rather than corporate quotas.
    • When you call or text, you reach Jim directly—no call centers, no layers, just personalized one-on-one support and guidance.
    • Handles hard-to-place coverage including motorcycles, ATVs, RVs, classic cars, watercraft, golf carts, and high-value home policies.
    Independent BrokerHomeowners InsuranceAuto InsuranceUmbrella LiabilityLife Insurance
    Phone(480) 637-5555
    Kreisman Insurance Group
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Phoenix, Carefree, Cave Creek, Rio Verde, and surrounding areas in Arizona and neighboring states
    ★★★★★5.0(88 Google reviews)

    Kaylene Meyer is a Farmers Insurance agent in Scottsdale with 25 years of industry experience, offering comprehensive insurance solutions including auto, home, renters, life, business, condo, and motorcycle coverage. She specializes in bundling policies to help clients save money and simplifies the insurance process through personalized service. Licensed in seven states (AZ, CA, CO, NV, OR, TX, WY), Kaylene serves the greater Phoenix area including Scottsdale, Phoenix, Carefree, Cave Creek, and Rio Verde.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Arizona homeowners seeking bundled auto and home insurance, small business owners, renters, life insurance shoppers, individuals relocating within western states
    What sets them apart
    • Kaylene brings over two decades of expertise to help clients navigate complex insurance options and find the right coverage for their needs.
    • Licensed to serve clients across seven states (AZ, CA, CO, NV, OR, TX, WY), providing flexibility for those with properties or relocating.
    • Offers auto, home, life, business, renters, condo, motorcycle, umbrella, and financial services with emphasis on bundling discounts and personalized coverage solutions.
    Insurance AgentAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceBundling DiscountsLife Insurance
    Phone(480) 460-8888
    Farmers Insurance - Kaylene Meyer
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale and greater Phoenix area, Arizona
    ★★★★★5.0(83 Google reviews)

    Blessed Coverage, led by Edward Leviyev, is an independent Medicare and health insurance brokerage specializing in helping Arizona seniors and families navigate complex insurance options. Edward offers free consultations for Medicare plans, ACA/Obamacare coverage, family health insurance, life insurance, and supplemental dental, vision, and hearing plans from multiple carriers. As an independent broker working on behalf of clients rather than carriers, he conducts in-depth reviews to match individuals with plans that meet their medical needs and budget, and assists clients in accessing available social programs and managing prescription costs.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Arizona seniors navigating Medicare, families without employer health coverage, individuals seeking ACA/Obamacare plans, families who lost Medicaid or AHCCCS coverage
    What sets them apart
    • All Medicare analysis and health insurance consultations are completely free. Edward conducts in-depth interviews to ensure clients understand all available options and social programs they may qualify for.
    • As a licensed independent broker, Edward works for clients, not carriers, ensuring recommendations are tailored to individual needs rather than carrier commissions.
    • Fluent in English, Russian, Hebrew, and Spanish to better serve diverse communities in the Phoenix area.
    MedicareHealth InsuranceIndependent BrokerFree ConsultationACA Insurance
    Blessed coverage
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Glendale, AZ · 21 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix metropolitan area, including Glendale, Phoenix, Peoria, Surprise, and surrounding communities
    ★★★★★5.0(82 Google reviews)

    State 48 Insurance Brokers of Arizona – Marisol Arnold Agency is an independent insurance brokerage serving the Phoenix metropolitan area with personalized coverage solutions. As an independent agent, Marisol Arnold works with multiple carriers to find clients the best rates and coverage options for auto, home, life, and business insurance. They focus on building long-term relationships and providing tailored insurance solutions rather than one-size-fits-all packages.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking bundled auto and home insurance, small business owners needing commercial coverage, families looking for life insurance protection, individuals comparing quotes from multiple carriers
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent broker, Marisol Arnold represents multiple insurance carriers, allowing clients to compare quotes and find the best coverage at competitive rates rather than being limited to a single company's offerings.
    • The agency focuses on understanding each client's unique insurance needs and building ongoing relationships, providing guidance on bundling discounts and policy optimization rather than transactional service.
    Independent Insurance AgentAuto & Home InsuranceBusiness InsuranceInsurance QuotesPhoenix Area
    Phone(480) 877-0048
    State 48 Insurance Brokers Of Arizona - Marisol Arnold Agency
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Mesa, AZ · 22 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Mesa, Arizona and surrounding communities
    ★★★★★5.0(75 Google reviews)

    Garrett Ranous is an independent Medicare insurance broker serving the Mesa area and surrounding communities. He specializes in helping Medicare-eligible clients navigate Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Prescription Drug plans to find coverage that fits their health needs and budget. With personalized consultation and ongoing support, Garrett helps seniors understand their options and avoid costly mistakes during enrollment periods.

    Best for: Comparing Options
    Ideal clients: Medicare-eligible seniors, retirees navigating plan changes, those comparing Medicare Advantage vs. Supplement coverage
    What sets them apart
    • Represents multiple carriers, not tied to a single insurance company, so recommendations are based on your needs rather than corporate incentives.
    • Focuses exclusively on Medicare options, providing deep knowledge of plans, coverage rules, and enrollment deadlines specific to seniors.
    • Takes time to understand individual health situations and budget constraints before recommending specific plans.
    Medicare InsuranceIndependent BrokerSenior HealthcareInsurance Consultation
    Phone(480) 323-8582
    Garrett Ranous, Medicare Insurance Broker
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale and Phoenix Valley, Arizona
    ★★★★★5.0(73 Google reviews)

    Don Neeley Agency is an independent insurance agency in Scottsdale serving families and businesses since 1992. They specialize in home insurance, auto insurance, boat insurance, and small business insurance, with a focus on personalized service and competitive rates. Run by Don Neeley and his team including Pat, the agency builds long-term relationships with clients by understanding their specific needs and finding affordable coverage solutions.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness Owners
    Ideal clients: Scottsdale families, small business owners, homeowners seeking personalized service, clients wanting competitive rates and long-term agent relationships
    What sets them apart
    • Operating since 1992, the agency prioritizes building lasting client relationships over volume, with many clients staying for 20+ years and becoming part of the 'family.'
    • The team works directly with clients to compare coverage options and find affordable pricing, with direct access to a real person rather than automated systems.
    • Offers comprehensive insurance solutions including home, auto, boat, and small business coverage, making them a one-stop shop for diverse insurance needs.
    Home InsuranceAuto InsuranceBusiness InsuranceIndependent AgentScottsdale
    Phone(480) 945-7621
    Don Neeley Agency
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 18 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix, Arizona and surrounding areas
    ★★★★★5.0(71 Google reviews)

    Insurance Ruff LLC is a family-owned and operated insurance agency in Phoenix serving Arizona with personalized insurance solutions. They partner with 71+ A-rated insurance companies to shop and compare rates across auto, home, life, business, umbrella, and specialty insurance products including condo, renters, motorcycle, motorhome, boat, and landlord coverage. Their approach prioritizes client needs with annual policy reviews to ensure customers maintain the best rates and coverage, plus instant online quotes and bonds available.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Arizona homeowners and auto owners seeking competitive rates, business owners needing commercial coverage, renters and specialty insurance buyers
    What sets them apart
    • Shops multiple A-rated insurance companies to ensure clients get competitive rates and optimal coverage across all policy types.
    • Proactively re-shops insurance at renewal to keep rates low and coverage aligned with changing needs.
    • Provides free instant auto and home quotes online, plus instant bond quotes, making the shopping process fast and convenient.
    Insurance BrokerMulti-Carrier AgencyArizona-BasedFree QuotesFamily-Owned
    Phone(602) 847-7888
    Insurance Ruff LLC
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Gilbert, AZ · 25 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Gilbert and greater Phoenix metropolitan area
    ★★★★★4.9(2213 Google reviews)

    Insurance Brokers of Arizona is an independent insurance agency in Gilbert specializing in personalized coverage solutions for individuals and businesses. They offer comprehensive home, auto, life, and commercial insurance policies from multiple carriers, allowing clients to compare options and find the best rates. The team takes a consultative approach to understand each client's unique needs and budget.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, auto insurance shoppers, small business owners, individuals seeking bundled coverage discounts
    What sets them apart
    • Works with numerous insurance companies to provide clients with multiple quotes and options, rather than being limited to one carrier's products.
    • Offers home, auto, life, and business insurance in one location, making it convenient to handle multiple policy needs with the same trusted advisor.
    • Based in Gilbert with deep knowledge of Arizona-specific insurance needs and local market conditions.
    Independent AgentMulti-Carrier OptionsLocal ExpertiseCustom Coverage
    Phone(480) 812-1998
    Insurance Brokers of Arizona
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 25 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding areas, Arizona
    ★★★★★4.9(1047 Google reviews)

    Acceptance Insurance in Phoenix offers a comprehensive range of insurance products including auto, renters, homeowners, motorcycle, SR-22, commercial, boat, RV, life, pet, and Mexican car insurance. The local office at 2929 N 75th Ave is staffed by experienced agents who research quotes from multiple carriers to find affordable coverage tailored to each customer's needs. They provide flexible shopping options through in-person visits, phone consultations, or online quotes, with a focus on helping Phoenix residents save money through bundling discounts and personalized policy recommendations.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Affordable car insurance shoppers, SR-22 drivers, renters, homeowners, motorcycle owners, small business owners
    What sets them apart
    • Local agents research quotes from multiple carriers to find the best rates and discounts for each customer's specific situation.
    • Beyond auto insurance, they offer homeowners, renters, motorcycle, SR-22, commercial, boat, RV, life, and pet insurance all in one location.
    • Customers can get quotes online, call the office, or visit in person for maximum convenience and flexibility.
    Auto InsuranceRenters InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceSR-22 InsuranceLocal Agent
    Phone(623) 233-7977
    Acceptance Insurance - N 75th Ave
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 16 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding Arizona communities
    ★★★★★4.9(444 Google reviews)

    Coriano Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency in Phoenix serving Arizona families and businesses with comprehensive coverage options. They specialize in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, offering personalized service and competitive rates through multiple carriers. With deep roots in the Phoenix community, they provide free quotes and help clients find bundled coverage that fits their specific needs.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Phoenix families needing auto and home insurance, small business owners seeking commercial coverage, individuals looking to bundle multiple policies
    What sets them apart
    • Coriano works with multiple insurance carriers, giving clients more options and competitive rates rather than being locked into one company's offerings.
    • They handle auto, home, life, and commercial insurance all in one place, making it convenient to bundle policies and potentially save on premiums.
    • Based in Phoenix with a strong community presence, they provide one-on-one consultation to match coverage to individual circumstances.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness Insurance
    Phone(602) 491-2550
    Websiteciaaz.com
    Coriano Insurance Agency
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Peoria, AZ · 23 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Peoria, Phoenix, and surrounding Maricopa County areas
    ★★★★★4.9(252 Google reviews)

    Lara Insurance Inc is an independent insurance agency in Peoria serving the greater Phoenix area with personalized coverage solutions. They specialize in auto, home, life, and business insurance, offering competitive rates and bundling discounts to help clients save money. Their experienced agents work directly with customers to understand their unique needs and find the right protection at the right price.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, auto owners, small business operators, families seeking multiple policies
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to find you the best rates and coverage options, rather than being limited to one company's products.
    • Combines auto, home, life, and business policies to maximize savings for customers who need multiple types of coverage.
    • Local agents take time to understand your specific situation and provide customized insurance recommendations rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceIndependent Agent
    Phone(623) 200-4230
    Lara Insurance Inc
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    84
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Arizona and surrounding Phoenix metro areas
    ★★★★★4.9(210 Google reviews)

    Logan the Insurance Guy is an independent insurance agency serving the Scottsdale area with comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and business insurance. As an independent agent, Logan works with multiple carriers to find clients the best rates and coverage tailored to their specific needs. The agency specializes in bundling policies for maximum savings and provides personalized service to help customers understand their options.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, auto owners, business owners, families seeking life insurance, customers wanting bundled multi-policy discounts
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to find competitive rates and coverage options rather than being limited to one company.
    • Specializes in combining auto, home, life, and business policies to maximize savings for customers.
    • Takes time to understand individual needs and explains coverage options clearly to ensure clients get appropriate protection.
    Independent AgentAuto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness Insurance
    Logan the Insurance Guy
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    83
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Arizona and greater Phoenix metropolitan area
    ★★★★★4.9(174 Google reviews)

    Empire Insurance Brokers is an independent insurance agency in Scottsdale offering comprehensive coverage for auto, home, life, and business insurance. As an independent broker, they work with multiple carriers to find personalized policies that fit each client's unique needs and budget. Their local team specializes in bundling discounts and providing free quotes to help Arizona residents and businesses protect what matters most.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking bundled auto and home insurance, small business owners, individuals comparing multiple carriers, anyone wanting personalized insurance advice
    What sets them apart
    • Work with multiple insurance carriers to find the best rates and coverage options, rather than being limited to a single company's products.
    • Provide no-obligation quotes to help you compare coverage and pricing before making any commitment.
    • Established local agency with personalized service and understanding of Arizona-specific insurance needs and market conditions.
    Independent Insurance BrokerAuto & Home InsuranceBusiness InsuranceFree QuotesLocal Agency
    Phone(480) 914-3240
    Websiteeibnow.com
    Empire Insurance Brokers
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    83
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 16 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding Arizona cities
    ★★★★★4.9(143 Google reviews)

    AZ Health Insurance Brokers is an independent health insurance agency serving the Phoenix area and beyond. They specialize in helping individuals, families, and small businesses navigate the complex health insurance landscape by offering personalized guidance on plan selection, enrollment, and claims support. With expertise across ACA marketplace plans, Medicare, and group coverage options, they work to match clients with affordable plans that fit their specific healthcare needs and budgets.

    Best for: Comparing Options
    Ideal clients: Self-employed professionals, Small business owners, Individuals seeking Medicare guidance, Families navigating health plan options
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent broker, they represent multiple insurance carriers, allowing them to compare plans and find the best fit for each client rather than being limited to a single company's offerings.
    • They provide one-on-one consultations to help clients understand plan options, coverage details, and out-of-pocket costs rather than directing them to navigate enrollment alone.
    • They assist with individual ACA marketplace plans, Medicare coverage, and group health insurance for small businesses, making them a full-service resource for diverse insurance needs.
    Health InsuranceIndependent BrokerMedicare PlansSmall Business Insurance
    Phone(602) 617-4107
    AZ Health Insurance Brokers
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 10 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix, Mesa, Scottsdale, Tempe, Chandler, Gilbert, and surrounding East Valley and West Valley communities
    ★★★★★5.0(609 Google reviews)

    Phoenix Health Insurance is an independent health and life insurance agency serving the Phoenix metro area with experienced licensed agents who specialize in individual and family health plans, Medicare policies, group health insurance, life insurance, dental plans, and financial products like annuities and long-term care coverage. Led by a team of seasoned professionals including Master General Agent Lynn Marble and Director Stacie Howard (with 16+ years of expertise), they provide personalized consultations to navigate complex insurance options and find coverage that fits each client's needs and budget.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Medicare-eligible seniors, families seeking individual or family health plans, small business owners needing group health coverage, individuals navigating ACA marketplace options
    What sets them apart
    • Multiple licensed agents with deep Medicare expertise help clients understand supplement plans and coverage gaps, with Master General Agent Lynn Marble and agent Stacie Howard leading this specialization.
    • Beyond health insurance, they offer life insurance, group benefits, dental plans, accident and critical illness coverage, long-term care, and annuities—providing one-stop financial protection planning.
    • They offer free evaluations for all products and services, and commit to being transparent if existing coverage is better than what they can provide.
    Health InsuranceMedicareLife InsuranceLicensed AgentsFree Consultations
    Phoenix Health Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 18 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding Phoenix metro area, Arizona
    ★★★★★4.8(347 Google reviews)

    Acceptance Insurance is a local insurance agency on West Bethany Home Road in Phoenix serving drivers and homeowners across Arizona. They offer auto insurance, home insurance, and other coverage options with a focus on providing quotes and policies for customers who may have difficulty finding affordable coverage elsewhere. The agency helps residents compare rates and bundle policies to maximize savings.

    Best for: HomeownersSaving Money
    Ideal clients: Phoenix drivers needing auto insurance, homeowners seeking coverage, customers looking to bundle policies, those shopping for competitive rates
    What sets them apart
    • Dedicated storefront location on West Bethany Home Road where customers can meet with agents in person to discuss coverage options and get quotes.
    • Specializes in helping customers combine auto and home insurance policies to reduce overall premium costs.
    • Works with drivers and homeowners who may have had difficulty obtaining affordable insurance through standard carriers.
    Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceLocal AgencyArizona CoverageInsurance Quotes
    Acceptance Insurance - W Bethany Home Rd
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 18 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix, Arizona and surrounding areas
    ★★★★★4.8(318 Google reviews)

    Acceptance Insurance is a local insurance agency in Phoenix offering auto insurance, home insurance, and other coverage options. They specialize in providing insurance solutions for customers who may have difficulty finding coverage elsewhere, including those with less-than-perfect driving records. Their knowledgeable team works to find affordable policies tailored to individual needs.

    Best for: Homeowners
    Ideal clients: High-risk drivers, customers with poor driving records, individuals seeking affordable multi-policy bundling
    What sets them apart
    • Accepts drivers with accidents, violations, or other factors that make it difficult to get coverage through standard insurers.
    • Offers auto insurance, home insurance, and additional coverage options to meet diverse customer needs under one roof.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceNon-Standard CoverageAffordable Rates
    Phone(602) 782-1585
    Acceptance Insurance - N 16th St
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    82
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 18 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding areas
    ★★★★★4.8(273 Google reviews)

    Acceptance Insurance is a local insurance agency in Phoenix offering auto, home, and life insurance coverage. As an independent agent, they provide personalized quotes and policy options from multiple carriers, helping customers find affordable coverage that fits their needs. They specialize in working with drivers who have had accidents, tickets, or lapses in coverage.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Drivers needing affordable auto insurance, homeowners seeking bundled coverage, customers with driving records or prior coverage gaps
    What sets them apart
    • Works with multiple insurance carriers to provide customers with personalized quotes and options from different companies.
    • Experienced in providing affordable insurance solutions for drivers with accidents, tickets, or coverage gaps in their history.
    • Offers auto, home, and life insurance under one roof for simplified policy management and bundling opportunities.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceIndependent Agent
    Phone(602) 782-1586
    Acceptance Insurance - N 35th Ave A4
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    81
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale and greater Phoenix metropolitan area
    ★★★★★5.0(70 Google reviews)

    Luxe Insurance Brokers is an independent insurance agency in Scottsdale specializing in personalized coverage solutions for homeowners, auto, life, and business insurance. As an independent broker, they work with multiple carriers to find competitive rates and customized policies tailored to each client's specific needs rather than pushing a single company's products.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners seeking comprehensive coverage, business owners needing commercial insurance, families looking to bundle auto and home policies, individuals wanting personalized insurance consultation
    What sets them apart
    • Work with multiple insurance carriers to compare rates and find the best coverage options for your specific situation, rather than being locked into a single company's offerings.
    • Offer homeowners, auto, life, and business insurance all in one place, allowing clients to bundle policies for potential discounts and simplified management.
    Independent Insurance AgencyMulti-Carrier OptionsPersonalized CoverageBusiness InsuranceHome & Auto
    Phone(480) 568-2566
    Luxe Insurance Brokers
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    80
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale and greater Phoenix metropolitan area
    ★★★★★4.9(232 Google reviews)

    Greene Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency in Scottsdale offering comprehensive coverage including auto, home, life, and business insurance. With access to multiple carriers and personalized service, they help Arizona residents and business owners find policies tailored to their specific needs and budgets.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Homeowners, auto owners, small business owners, families seeking bundled coverage
    What sets them apart
    • Access to multiple insurance carriers allows them to compare quotes and find the best rates and coverage options for each client rather than pushing a single company's products.
    • Handles auto, home, life, and business insurance, making them a one-stop shop for families and business owners with multiple coverage needs.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceBusiness InsuranceIndependent Agent
    Greene Insurance Group
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    80
    Lantern
    Score
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Serves Scottsdale, Arizona and surrounding Phoenix metropolitan areas
    ★★★★★4.9(229 Google reviews)

    Debra Atkinson is a local Allstate Insurance agent in Scottsdale offering comprehensive coverage including auto, home, life, and business insurance. With personalized service and access to Allstate's full suite of products, she helps individuals and families find the right insurance solutions for their needs.

    Best for: HomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Auto insurance shoppers, homeowners seeking coverage, families looking for life insurance, small business owners
    What sets them apart
    • Offers a comprehensive range of insurance products including auto, home, life, and business coverage through Allstate's established network.
    • Provides personalized service and local market knowledge to help clients select appropriate coverage for their specific situation.
    Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceLife InsuranceAllstate Agent
    Phone(480) 741-6951
    Debra Atkinson: Allstate Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    79
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 14 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding Arizona areas
    ★★★★★5.0(13 Google reviews)

    AZ Medicare Insurance Agents/Brokers, operating as Kelley Services, Inc., specializes in helping Arizona seniors navigate Medicare options and enrollment. The team provides personalized guidance on Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans to ensure clients select coverage that matches their healthcare needs and budget. Based in Phoenix with a Tucson phone number, they serve seniors throughout Arizona seeking expert Medicare consultation.

    Ideal clients: Arizona seniors turning 65, Medicare beneficiaries seeking plan changes, individuals comparing Supplement and Advantage options
    What sets them apart
    • Dedicated expertise in Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans specific to Arizona seniors, rather than general insurance.
    • Agents work one-on-one with clients to understand healthcare needs and budgets to recommend appropriate coverage options.
    Medicare PlansSenior InsuranceHealth CoverageArizona Seniors
    Phone(520) 907-5132
    AZ Medicare Insurance Agents/Brokers - Kelley Services, Inc.
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →
    79
    Lantern
    Score
    Phoenix, AZ · 16 mi from Scottsdale
    Serves Phoenix and surrounding Maricopa County communities
    ★★★★★4.8(466 Google reviews)

    Arizona Preferred Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Phoenix offering comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, life, and commercial insurance. With over 466 client reviews, they specialize in helping individuals and businesses find the right coverage at competitive rates through their access to multiple carriers.

    Best for: Comparing OptionsHomeownersBusiness OwnersSaving MoneyLife Insurance Planning
    Ideal clients: Phoenix-area homeowners, auto insurance shoppers, small business owners, individuals seeking bundled coverage discounts
    What sets them apart
    • As an independent agency, Arizona Preferred Insurance represents multiple carriers, giving clients access to a wider range of quotes and coverage options compared to captive agents.
    • Based in Phoenix with deep familiarity with Arizona-specific insurance needs, from desert climate considerations to local liability factors.
    Independent InsuranceAuto & HomeBusiness InsurancePhoenix Insurance
    Phone(602) 266-0020
    Arizona Preferred Insurance
    Updated 4/21/26Learn More →

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Who is the top-ranked insurance agent in Scottsdale?

    Insurance Professionals of Arizona is the top-ranked agency in the Scottsdale area with a Lantern Score of 85.83/100 and a 5★ rating from 1,830 reviews. They specialize in auto, home, life, and commercial coverage solutions for Arizona families and businesses.

    Which insurance agents serve Scottsdale families with auto and home insurance?

    Jeremy Mueller - State Farm Insurance Agent (Lantern Score: 85.68/100) has been serving Scottsdale families since 1999 and offers auto, homeowners, and life insurance. Don Neeley Agency (Lantern Score: 84.22/100) also specializes in home and auto insurance for Scottsdale families and has served the area since 1992.

    What insurance options are available for small business owners in Scottsdale?

    Several top-ranked agencies serve small business owners: Shisler & Associates Insurance (Lantern Score: 85.65/100) offers comprehensive commercial coverage, while Pinnacle Peak Insurance Group (Lantern Score: 85.32/100) and Empire Insurance Brokers (Lantern Score: 83.47/100) both provide business insurance solutions alongside auto and home coverage.

    Which insurance agents specialize in Medicare for Arizona seniors?

    Blessed Coverage (Lantern Score: 84.41/100) specializes in Medicare and health insurance for Arizona seniors, while Garrett Ranous, Medicare Insurance Broker (Lantern Score: 84.26/100) focuses on Medicare Advantage and Supplement plans. Phoenix Health Insurance (Lantern Score: 82.09/100) also serves Medicare-eligible seniors with 5★ ratings from 609 reviews.

    Who offers independent insurance brokerage with access to multiple carriers?

    Professional Insurance Strategies (Lantern Score: 85.13/100) works with over 50 insurance carriers to provide multi-carrier options. Insurance Ruff LLC (Lantern Score: 84.17/100) partners with 71+ A-rated insurance companies, and Kreisman Insurance Group (Lantern Score: 84.76/100) is an independent broker with over 23 years of experience.

    Which agencies are best for bundling auto and home insurance in Scottsdale?

    Shisler & Associates Insurance (Lantern Score: 85.65/100) and State 48 Insurance Brokers - Marisol Arnold Agency (Lantern Score: 84.39/100) specialize in bundled auto and home coverage. Empire Insurance Brokers (Lantern Score: 83.47/100) in Scottsdale also focuses on helping homeowners bundle multiple policies for better rates.

    This directory of insurance agents local businesses serving Scottsdale, AZ is maintained by Lantern. Rankings are determined by the Lantern Score — not advertising or payment for placement. Learn how it works. Last updated April 21, 2026. To claim or update a listing, contact us.